Unraveling the Mystery: Was Seiza the 'Correct' Way to Sit for Sengoku Women? A Deep Dive with Professor Kazuto Hongo's History Quiz

Photo by Mat Kedzia on Pexels

Imagine yourself transported to the tumultuous Sengoku Period of Japan. The air crackles with tension, the clang of steel echoes across battlefields, and formidable castles stand as silent sentinels to tales of ambition, betrayal, and unwavering loyalty. While samurai lords plotted their next moves, what of the women who sustained this complex society? Often relegated to the background in popular narratives, their lives were equally rich with drama, strategy, and distinct cultural norms.

One seemingly simple aspect of daily life, often taken for granted, can offer a surprising window into this past: the way people sat. Specifically, was Seiza (the formal kneeling posture) the universally accepted, "correct way to sit" for Sengoku Period women? This intriguing question, which challenges many modern perceptions, was recently posed by Professor Kazuto Hongo in an interesting Japanese history quiz, originally featured in 婦人公論.jp. Let's journey back in time to explore what historical evidence, particularly medieval emakimono (picture scrolls), truly reveals.

The Sengoku Period: Beyond Battles and Bushido

The Sengoku Period (roughly 1467-1615) was an era of constant warfare, but it was also a time of significant cultural and social development. While the focus often falls on figures like Oda Nobunaga, Toyotomi Hideyoshi, and Tokugawa Ieyasu, the women of this era played indispensable roles. They managed households, raised children, engaged in diplomacy, and sometimes even wielded political influence behind the scenes. Their lives, though often confined by societal expectations, were far from passive.

Understanding the nuances of their daily existence, from their attire to their customs, helps us paint a more complete picture of history. And as Professor Kazuto Hongo's quiz highlights, even something as fundamental as a sitting posture can hold unexpected historical truths.

Unpacking the Seiza Question: Professor Hongo's Insight

The image of a Japanese person sitting in perfect Seiza is deeply ingrained in our collective consciousness as a symbol of tradition and etiquette. But was this always the case? Professor Kazuto Hongo's interesting Japanese history quiz challenges us to consider if Seiza was, in fact, the predominant or "correct way to sit" for Sengoku Period women. His prompt directs us to a crucial historical source: medieval emakimono.

What Medieval Emakimono Reveal About Seating

When we delve into medieval emakimono (picture scrolls) – invaluable visual records of daily life, rituals, and narratives from Japan's past – a different picture emerges. These scrolls, meticulously detailed and vibrant, depict men and women in a variety of postures. While some forms of kneeling might be present, what is often depicted is a range of more relaxed, practical sitting positions. For example, women are frequently shown sitting with their legs folded to one side (yoko-zuwari), or with one knee raised, or even cross-legged (agura), particularly in less formal settings or during daily activities.

The notion of Seiza as the singular "correct way to sit" for all formal occasions, especially for women, appears to be a much later development. Historical research suggests that while kneeling postures existed, the strict, formal Seiza we recognize today became widespread and codified primarily during the Edo Period (1603-1868), evolving as part of samurai etiquette and later spreading to general society. For Sengoku Period women, practicality and comfort likely dictated their posture more than a rigid formal convention, especially during long hours of work or social interaction.

Beyond Posture: The Drama of Daily Life

This revelation from Professor Hongo's quiz isn't just about a sitting position; it’s about challenging our assumptions and appreciating the fluidity of history. It reminds us that historical practices were not static and often differed significantly from their later idealized forms. For the women of the Sengoku Period, navigating a society in constant upheaval, their daily lives were a blend of resilience and adaptation. From the wives of powerful daimyo who managed vast estates to the common women who kept the economy running, their ability to adapt to changing circumstances was paramount.

The subtle details, like how they sat, give us a glimpse into their realities—a world where practicality often took precedence, and etiquette was perhaps less rigid than we imagine. These insights allow us to connect with history on a deeply human level, seeing the people of the past not as static figures, but as individuals living dynamic, complex lives.

Conclusion: Redefining Our View of Sengoku Women

Professor Kazuto Hongo's interesting Japanese history quiz offers a fascinating challenge to our preconceived notions. By carefully examining sources like medieval emakimono, we learn that the assumption of Seiza as the sole "correct way to sit" for Sengoku Period women is likely a historical anachronism. Instead, the visual evidence suggests a more diverse and less formal approach to seating in their daily lives.

This journey back in time, guided by the insights of historians, allows us to move beyond simplified narratives and appreciate the rich, nuanced tapestry of the past. It reminds us that history is not just about grand battles and political intrigue, but also about the everyday lives of people, including the strong and adaptable Sengoku Period women, whose stories continue to unfold with every new discovery.