The New Sengoku Jidai: Why Shopping Centers Face a Brutal "Warring States Period" Where Tenants Exit in 3 Months

Photo by Quí Trần on Pexels

Step back in time with me, not to an ancient battlefield, but to a modern arena where the stakes are just as high and the competition just as fierce. We are witnessing the unfolding of what can only be described as a "Warring States Period" (Sengoku Jidai) for shopping centers, a brutal era where the landscape shifts with dizzying speed, and survival demands the cunning of a daimyō.

The Echoes of Sengoku: A Time of Unrest

Imagine 16th-century Japan. The central authority of the shogunate had crumbled, leaving a power vacuum. Across the archipelago, ambitious daimyō rose, each vying for supremacy, building formidable castles not just as fortresses, but as centers of administration, commerce, and culture. These castles—like Oda Nobunaga’s magnificent Azuchi Castle, a symbol of his vision and power, or Toyotomi Hideyoshi’s Osaka Castle—were strategic strongholds designed to attract people, resources, and influence. They were the hubs where merchants gathered, artisans thrived, and populations settled, all under the protective, yet demanding, gaze of their lord.

The era was defined by relentless expansion, strategic alliances, sudden betrayals, and the dramatic rise and fall of clans. New castles would appear, challenging the dominance of older ones. Those who failed to adapt, to innovate their defenses or their economic policies, quickly vanished into the annals of history. The very notion that one could simply "build prolifically" (bamban dekinai) without a clear strategy was unthinkable; every construction was a calculated move in a grand, dangerous game.

Castles of Commerce: The Modern Battlefield

Fast forward to today, and the parallels are striking. Our modern "castles" are the vast, gleaming shopping centers that dot the urban and suburban landscapes. For decades, the strategy was simple: build bigger, build more, and the "tenants" (tenanto)—the shops, restaurants, and entertainment venues—would flock to your walls, and customers would follow. This expansion was, for a time, a winning formula, mirroring the initial land grabs of ambitious daimyō.

However, the era of easy expansion is over. Just as the Sengoku period saw the eventual consolidation of power and the end of indiscriminate castle building, the retail world has reached a saturation point. The prevailing sentiment is now: "もう、ショッピングセンターはバンバンできない！" – we can no longer simply build shopping centers one after another without facing dire consequences.

The Brutal Reality: When "3 Months" Spells Doom

The "Warring States Period" for shopping centers is not merely a metaphor; it's a harsh economic reality. The competition is so intense, the market so saturated, that we are seeing unprecedented situations. Imagine a tenant, a merchant who has invested heavily in setting up shop within one of these grand retail "castles," only to find themselves struggling to survive. The situation has become so severe that some tenants are being forced to exit after just 3 months (オープンから3カ月で退店のテナントも) from opening their doors.

This rapid turnover is a clear indicator of the "too harsh Warring States Period" (厳しすぎる“戦国時代”) that has descended upon the industry. Why this brutal shift? Like the daimyō who faced new challenges from firearms and shifting alliances, shopping centers today contend with a multitude of factors: the relentless rise of e-commerce, changing consumer demographics and spending habits, and an overwhelming supply of retail space.

For a tenant to leave after such a short period signifies a profound miscalculation or an inability to adapt to the fierce competition. It’s akin to a minor lord losing their newly built outpost due to a surprise attack or economic failure, unable to sustain their presence against more powerful rivals or changing times.

Beyond "Bamban Dekinai": Strategies for Survival

So, what does history teach us about surviving such a tumultuous period? The most successful daimyō were not just powerful; they were strategic. They understood their territory, innovated their military tactics, and cultivated loyalty through good governance and economic prosperity. Similarly, today's shopping centers and their tenants must:

• Innovate and Differentiate: No longer can a shopping center simply be a collection of stores. It must offer unique experiences, community engagement, and a compelling reason for people to leave their homes and venture into its walls. Like a castle town offering specialized crafts or unique festivals, modern centers must provide something beyond mere transactions.
• Strategic Alliances: Tenants and landlords must work in closer partnership, understanding that their fates are intertwined. This means flexible lease agreements, shared marketing efforts, and a collective vision for the "castle's" future.
• Adaptability: The daimyō who survived were those who could adapt to new technologies and threats. Shopping centers must be agile, ready to pivot to new trends, integrate technology seamlessly, and cater to evolving consumer desires.
• Understanding the Terrain: A deep understanding of the local market, demographics, and competitive landscape is crucial. Not every castle can be a grand fortress; some must be specialized outposts serving niche needs.

The Legacy of Strategy

The "Warring States Period" in retail is not a temporary blip; it’s a fundamental shift in the industry. The days of simply building more and expecting success are long gone. The current environment, where tenants exit after just 3 months, is a stark reminder of the immense pressure and the need for strategic brilliance. Just as the daimyō of old carved out their domains through shrewd planning and relentless effort, so too must today's retail players hone their strategies to survive and thrive in this unforgiving new era. The echoes of history remind us: only the most adaptable, innovative, and strategically sound will endure.